Cumaru vs Manbarklak
Dipteryx odorata against Eschweilera spp.. Every number below names the publication it came from.
| Property | Cumaru | Manbarklak |
|---|---|---|
| Janka hardness | 3,415 lbfLPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 3,480 lbfUSDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 5-5b |
| Density at 12% MC | 66.8 lb/ft³LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 46.2 lb/ft³LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras |
| Modulus of rupture | 24,371 lb/in²LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 26,500 lb/in²USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 5-5b |
| Modulus of elasticity | 2.43 ×10⁶ lb/in²LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 3.14 ×10⁶ lb/in²USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 5-5b |
| Crushing strength | 14,742 lb/in²LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 11,210 lb/in²USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 5-5b |
| Volumetric shrinkage(lower is better) | 13.5%LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 15.9%USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 4-4 |
| Tangential / radial ratio(lower is better) | 1.56LPF/SFB Madeiras Brasileiras | 1.78USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 4-4 |
What the numbers mean
- The two match on hardness, within 2%. Choose on movement or on appearance instead.
- Cumaru moves more evenly. Its tangential-to-radial ratio is 1.6 against 1.8, so it is the safer choice for a wide flat panel.
- Manbarklak carries 9% more load in bending, which matters for a shelf or a rail.
- Cumaru is the heavier of the two by 330 kg/m³, which a reader building a door or a case should weigh.
Sources
- LPF/SFB Madeiras BrasileirasCC BY 4.0
- USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) eq. 4-9public domain
- USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 5-5bpublic domain
- USDA Wood Handbook 2021 (FPL-GTR-282) Table 4-4public domain
Estimates are labeled beside their values. A dash means no published value is available. Properties describe the source material; individual boards vary.